【新唐人2011年11月22日讯】大陆左派人士司马南，刚刚因为污蔑艺术家艾未未与盲人维权律师陈光诚，被深圳一名女子千里进京“砸场”。 19号，在“中国青年政治学院”再遭大学生们尖锐提问，司马南大动肝火，厉声要学生“闭嘴”。事后，民众为这些学生叫好，认为：从这些学生身上，看到了中国的希望。
11月19号晚间，大陆左派人士司马南在“中国青年政治学院”进行了一场演讲。学生们在现场交流互动时，提出了几个很犀利的问题。第二天，大陆网站上出现了这段名为“司马南演讲现场遭遇大学生尖锐提问”的现场视频集锦。
穿黑色夹克衫的男生：“毛泽东思想在建国前30年的实践之中，1958年反右扩大98%，1959年至1961年3000万人的白骨，1966年至1976年文革稀里糊涂。包括毛泽东思想的外输，在柬埔寨建立的波尔布特红色高棉政权，导致柬埔寨700万人口之中，死亡超过200万。通过这一系列的，包括在打天下、治天下的过程之中，毛泽东思想所产生的一些问题，还包括学术上、逻辑论述上的一些困难，你如何还能在今天来提升毛泽东思想？”
另一位穿羽绒服的男生质问司马南，山东盲人维权人士陈光诚，为何被严密监禁，网友去看他却被殴打，为什么这些打人的人可以不遵守宪法?
一位身穿红色外套的男生则联系台湾的宪政，向司马南提问：在大陆，连人大代表候选人是怎么产生的都不知道，独立参选人被当局打压，公民没有选举权的政治制度难道是合理的吗?
还有一位男生质疑司马南，你号称“中共代表人民的利益”。但为什么，作为人民的一员，我们要被当局强制灌输某一种特定的意识形态呢？
男生：“我们从小就在政治课上，接受马克思主义的洗脑，但是我们认为，我们每个人都是不同的个体，理应有权利接受不同的理念，并从中选择自己的政治理念。我们要自己选择某种政治理念，作为在这个世界对政治的看法。你是否认为，执政当局安排的政治洗脑课，是对我们个人政治认识的侵犯？”
每一位学生发言过后，现场都爆发出热烈的掌声。但学生们的踊跃提问，却经常遭到司马南的呵斥与威胁。
学生：“这个问题就反映出，你没有用学术的态度来研究这些问题。”
司马南：“不要这样子说话，你要是再说…”
学生：“我第一次面对’国际五毛’，我有点激动，真的。”
司马南更是在窘迫之下，失态的不断训斥一位想要发言的男生“闭嘴！”
这段视频曝光后，立即走红网络，引发很多网民的共鸣。网友感叹：谁说，中国的春天永远不会到来？希望就在当下，就在民众的心中。
美国纽约城市大学政治学教授夏明表示，在当局高压封锁之下，这些年轻人能够有这么清晰的认识，说明中共面临越来越大的挑战。
夏明教授：“现在我们看到的是90后这一代了，尽管他们没有参与89（64学生运动），但是他们已经接上来了，所以这一点，让我觉得：中国目前发生大变化，这种基础逐渐在出现。”
夏明教授指出，司马南依附当权者，用政权撑腰，进行炒作、获取名利。司马南居高临下的教训学生说明，他的演讲是在灌输，而不是正常的双向互动与交流。
夏明教授：“演讲本身如果没有听众的话，你就没有演讲。而如果听众没办法参与到整个演讲过程的话，这个演讲就不是一个对话，而是一种灌输和说教了。显然，司马南想要维护的是一种说教的格局和说教的模式。”
前些年，司马南曾经配合当局，竭力反对当局认定的所谓“伪科学”，也因此和何祚庥、方舟子一起，被网民讥讽为：不懂科学，却自命“反伪斗士”。近来，他活跃在左派网站上，频频挑战公众言论，被网民称为“五毛党”党魁。
新唐人记者常春、李谦 、孙宁采访报导。
Embarrassed Sima Nan Shouts “Shut Up” at Students
Recently, a young girl from Shenzhen l travelled to
Beijing to denounce Sima Nan during his lecture,
because Sima had slandered artist Ai Weiwei and
blind activist lawyer Chen Guangcheng.
On Nov. 19, students again waged sharp questions to
him at China Youth University for Political Sciences.
Enraged, Sima Nan urged students to “shut up."
Later, people applauded these students,
saying that they saw China’s future through these students.
The evening of Nov. 19, Mainland leftist Sima Nan delivered
a speech at China Youth University for Political Sciences.
Students waged a number of very sensitive questions.
The next day, a video appeared on Mainland internet named
“Sima Nan again Encounters Embarrassing Questions at Speech.”
One male student was quoted saying:
Maoism incurred a series of problems.
During the years of 1959-1961 it caused 30
million unnatural deaths, followed by the Cultural Revolution.
Outside China, Maoism gave rise to the Khmer Rouge regime
in Cambodia, which killed over 2 million of 7 million people.
Given all these historical problems, together with academic
and logical problems within Maoism, how can you inherit it today?
Another student asked Sima, why Shandong blind activist
Chen Guangcheng was detained, and his visitors beaten.
Why can those that beat people not abide by
the Constitution?
One of the boys in the audience mentioned
Taiwan’s constitutional politics.
He questioned Mainland’s election system where people
do not know how candidates are produced and independent candidates are suppressed by the authorities.
Another student said, CCP claims to represent people’s
interests, but why, as part of the people, are students forced to accept a particular kind of ideology?
We grew up with ideological indoctrination and Marxist
brainwashing,
but we believe that each of us is an independent
individual, with the right to choose political philosophy.
Do you think the authority’s political brainwashing
is a violation of our own personal political choice?
Each question was followed by an eruption of applause,
but Sima Nan denounced and threatened the students for the questions.
One student exclaimed: Thus it proves that you are not taking
an academic attitude towards this issue.
Sima: Do not talk like this. If you say it again, …
Student again replied: It is the first time that I face an “international fifty-cents.
I am a little excited, really."
Embarrassed, Sima Nan constantly rebuked
the student to “shut up!"
This video immediately became popular after its release.
Netizens said, who says China’s spring will never come?
Hope is in the moment, in the hearts of the people!
Xia Ming, professor of political science at City University
of NY, said that these young people demonstrated such consciousness under CCP’s high pressure,
indicating increasing challenges to CCP.
Professor Xia Ming said,
“Now we see this post-90s generation growing up.
Although they did not participate in “Tian’anmen Massacre,”
they did however inherit its spirit.
This makes me feel that China is undergoing a major change
that is now taking shape”.
Professor Xia Ming pointed out Sima Nan collaborated with
CCP for fame and fortune.
His condescending scolding to the students shows that
he indoctrinates instead of communicates.
Professor Xia Ming says, without an audience,
a speech does not count as speech.
Without an audiences participation,
a speech is not communication but indoctrination.
It is clear that Sima Nan tries to maintain a pattern of
preaching and indoctrinating.
Some years ago, Sima collaborated with CCP to denounce
the so-called “pseudo-sciences."
Together with He Zuoxiu and Fang Zhouzi,
Sima received netizens’ criticism as an unscientific fighter against pseudo-sciences.
Recently, he was active in left-wing websites
to frequently challenge public opinions.
He thus received the title Chairman of Fifty-Cent Party.
NTD Reporters Chang Chun, Li Qian and Sun Ning
