【新唐人2013年04月25日訊】大陸《Lens視覺》雜誌記者袁凌,在最新一期雜誌報導了《走出「馬三家」》文章,遼寧當局迅速成立調查小組,聲稱將針對文章中,親身經歷勞教所酷刑者所描述的事實真相展開調查。日前,馬三家調查報告出爐,但袁凌提出聲明說:要與遼寧教養院當庭對質,並要追究製造假新聞的調查組人員,和《法制網》記者、以及《新華網》等誹謗責任。
遼寧省調查「馬三家勞教所」酷刑虐待被勞教人員的報告說,「《走出「馬三家」》一文內容嚴重失實」。
報導「馬三家」的袁凌,北京時間4月22號13點42分,在新浪實名微博發表聲明,他說:「建議遼寧教養院起訴本人,雙方當庭對質,出示人證物證。若我果然造謠污衊,盡可追究刑責。若報導屬實,也請法庭追究教養所虐待者以及包庇的司法廳官員刑責。此外,要公開調查組成員名單,追究製造假新聞的調查組人員和法制網記者霍仕明、新華網的誹謗責任,向本人賠禮道歉,消除惡劣影響。」
這份聲明被新浪微博刪除,但是被拷貝儲存在「自由微博」網站上。
袁凌在微博上還曝光遼寧省司法廳調查工作領導小組4月9號的密件,密件要求調查組「按照省委,省政府領導的指示和省廳黨組的部署,力爭在3-5天內完成調查工作,爭取時間開展輿論應對和正面輿論引導工作,掌握輿論工作的主動權。」
袁凌還披露,當初他到遼寧省司法廳及勞教局採訪時,被推三阻四踢皮球。找勞教局地址就費了半天,原來隱藏在一家豪華的歌廳門面之後。當時辦公室人員拒絕他的採訪並且說,想怎麼寫就怎麼寫。
與《Lens》雜誌同屬中國《財訊》傳媒集團的《財經》雜誌副主編羅昌平,4月22號在微博貼文,他向《人民網》的兩名記者致敬,因為他們作為調查組受邀成員,拒絕在「內容嚴重失實」的結論上簽字。
《新唐人》致電羅昌平,他表示不方便接受採訪。
《新唐人》記者:「那兩個《人民網》的記者,他為甚麼參與了調查組呢?」
大陸《財經》雜誌副主編:「調查者他邀請了媒體的人員。從一開始公開,你可以查一下那條新聞。中央的一些媒體,包括中央媒體駐遼寧的,他們都邀請了。」
記者:「那他們具體進行了哪些調查?是如何調查的呢?」
羅昌平:「這個不知道。不好意思。我不方便接受採訪。」
記者:「那這個調查組由哪些人組成呢?」
羅昌平:「你在網上查一下。網上有網友把他們弄出來了。有司法部的,然後他們勞教局的局長,也是一個副組長。」
在調查組「結論」發表的當天——4月20號中午,黨媒《光明日報》下屬的《光明網》刊登評論員文章:《馬三家、打的報導失實,真相是甚麼》。
報導說,以《走出「馬三家」》一文所描述的情節,如果其中事實為真,則虐待被勞教人員的施虐者已然構成刑事犯罪。
報導認為,走法律程序,讓兩造對簿公堂,由此就更容易使真相大白於天下。
大陸民間獨立學者鄭志遙認為,馬三家黑幕的披露,和調查組結果的出爐,以及《光明網》的反擊,反映出中共高層的分裂和搏擊。
大陸民間獨立學者 鄭志遙:「我認為馬三家的事情,就是在一個我們大家都看不到的黑箱子或者幕後,有人不小心拉開一道縫隙,讓人看到舞臺後面,啊,後面很亂。」
鄭志遙表示,遼寧調查組的副組長,就是原來「馬三家教養院」的院長。他們成立的調查組,肯定是掩蓋。
而大陸自由作家王藏表示,從中共建政以來,一直以「反人類」等各種暴行對待民眾。遼寧調查組斷然否認馬三家的酷刑虐待,正是中共極權暴政一以貫之的做法。
採訪編輯/秦雪 後製/葛雷
Masanjia Torture’Denial Challenged by a Reporter
Yuan Ling, China-based Lens magazine journalist, published
an article, “Walking out of Masanjia" in the latest issue.
Liaoning authorities quickly formed an investigation team,
claiming to find the truth of Masanjia torture incidents.
They came up with an investigation conclusion, however,
Yuan challenged the Liaoning labor camp to meet in court.
In addition, Yuan requested authorities to punish
those who made false news,
which involves members of the investigation team,
and reporters of the Legal Daily website,
plus a reporter from the Xinhua news website;
they should be all punished for defamation.
The investigation report said,"‘Walking out of Masanjia’
article is seriously inconsistent with the facts."
At 13:42pm on April 22, Yuan Ling posted a statement
on Sina microblog: “I suggest Liaoning Labor Camp sue me.
We, both sides, can meet in court,
bringing in witnesses and evidences.
If I really fabricated the article,
you can charge me.
If my report is true, please hand in to the Justice Department
the Masanjia’s abusers and those shielding the criminals.
In addition, please publicize the name list
of the investigation team.
Please punish those involved in making false news
in the investigation team, including Legal Daily reporter Huo Shiming, and reporters of the Xinhua website.
They need to send apologies to me,
in order to rectify the bad impact they had on me."
Yuan’s statement was deleted from Sina microblog,
but a copy was saved in freeweibo.com.
There Yuan exposes a secret document from Liaoning
Justice Department Investigation Team on April 9.
The file says,"In accordance with the orders from leaders
in provincial government and party committee, the investigation must be done in 3-5 days;
win some time to deal with public opinion,
and positively guide the public opinion;
grasp the initiative of the opportunity
to work on the public opinion."
Yuan also revealed that when he went to Liaoning Justice
Department and Labor Bureau to do the interview, they gave him many excuses to pass the ball around.
He spent half a day just looking for the Labor Bureau’s address,
finding it to be located behind a luxury karaoke club.
An official clerk there refused him an interview,
and told Yuan to write whatever he likes.
On April 22, Caijing magazine deputy editor,
Luo Changping posted messages on a microblog.
He sent his respects to the two journalists of Renmin website,
who were members of the investigation team, but refused to sign the fabricated conclusive report.
NTD contacted Luo Changping for an interview.
NTD reporter: “Why were the two Renmin website"
Luo Changping, Caijing deputy editor:
“The investigators invited these journalists.
Earlier, they publicized the news,
one can search for that online.
They invited media from the central government,
including Liaoning branch media, they were invited."
NTD reporter:"What investigation did they do?
How is being proceeded?"
Luo Changping:"I don’t know about it. I am very sorry,
it is not convenient for me to give interviews."
NTD reporter:"What kind of people
were in the investigation team?"
Luo Changping:"This can be searched online.
Netizens had posted about it.
It had Justice Ministry’people, and a Labor Bureau’director,
he was also a vice leader of the investigation team."
On April 20, the day of the investigation report release,
state-owned media Guangming published an editorial article,
titled,"Masanjia, Fabricated Taxi Report (referring to
a recent report on Xi Jinping’Taxi Ride,) What Is True?"
The article said that according to"Walking out of Masanjia"
the abusers who tortured inmates had committed crimes.
The article stated that following the proceedings,
both sides will need to meet in court to clarify the truth.
Zheng Zhiyao, a scholar in Mainland China,
believes that the exposure on Masanjia’s torture,
the investigation team’s conclusion, and Guangming’s
response reflect Chinese Communist Party (CCP) top split.
Zheng Zhiyao:"I think Masanjia incidents happened behind
the scene; someone accidentally opened the curtain and people saw the back stage, ah, what a mess!"
Zheng said, the vice head of the Liaoning investigation team
was a former director in the Masanjia Labor Camp.
Thus, this investigation team was formed
for covering up the truth.
Wang Zang, Mainland’s freelance writer said, since its dawn,
CCP hasn’t stopped committing crimes against humanity.
Liaoning’s investigation group categorically denied
the facts of the brutal tortures in Masanjia.
This is just another example
of CCP’s dictatorship doing what it always has.